We'd appreciate your feedback. Send feedback Subscribe to our newsletters and alerts


Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior

2025 Volume 5 Issue 1

Why Belonging Fails Without Voice, Influence, and Organizational Power


, , ,
  1. Department of Belonging and Voice, Faculty of Business, University of Dundee, Dundee, United Kingdom.
  2. Department of Influence and Organizational Power, Faculty of Management, Newcastle University, Newcastle, United Kingdom.
  3. Department of Work Inclusion, Faculty of Psychology, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, United Kingdom.
Abstract

Belonging has become a central objective of contemporary inclusion efforts, yet membership, acceptance, and interpersonal recognition do not necessarily provide employees with consequential influence over organizational decisions. This Original Conceptual Framework Article develops a proposed Belonging–Power Framework to distinguish four analytically separate conditions: belonging and legitimate membership, voice access, influence conversion, and organizational power or resource authority. The framework integrates evidence on inclusion, employee voice, hierarchy, endorsement, implementation, structural inequality, and policy–practice decoupling while preserving distinctions between individual experience and organizational structure. It proposes that inclusion can become substantively incomplete when employees are welcomed or heard but remain unable to affect recurring decisions, resource allocations, or rules that shape their work. Three conversion problems are emphasized: belonging without usable voice, voice without consequential uptake, and episodic influence without durable authority. Structural barriers and dependency on gatekeepers are treated as cross-cutting conditions rather than assumed universal mechanisms. The article further proposes diagnostic dimensions for separating sentiment, access, response, implementation, and authority, while rejecting unvalidated thresholds or readiness scores. The framework is intended to organize testable propositions and comparative research, not to establish a causal sequence or prescribe equal authority across all decisions. Its contribution is a bounded conceptual architecture for examining when inclusion reflects meaningful participation and when apparently inclusive membership remains dependent, symbolic, or structurally constrained.


How to cite this article
Vancouver
Wilson G, Bennett C, Wright E, Turner J. Why Belonging Fails Without Voice, Influence, and Organizational Power. J Appl Organ Syst Behav. 2025;5(1):107-16. https://doi.org/10.51847/P0JFpVFa32
APA
Wilson, G., Bennett, C., Wright, E., & Turner, J. (2025). Why Belonging Fails Without Voice, Influence, and Organizational Power. Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior, 5(1), 107-116. https://doi.org/10.51847/P0JFpVFa32
Articles
Navigating the Mind of Gen Z Investors: Behavioral Factors and Stock Decision-Making in Vietnam
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 4 Issue 2, 2024 | Beatrice Mwangi
Forming Family Concepts in Pre-Adolescents Living in Orphanages
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 5 Issue 2, 2025 | Sanne Bakker
Understanding and Regulating Irrationality in Economic Decision-Making
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 5 Issue 1, 2025 | Isabelle Laurent
The Interplay of Spiritual Insight, Self-Actualization, and Educational Excellence
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 5 Issue 2, 2025 | Natalia Petrova
Faith, Work, and Obligation: Factors Shaping Zakat Compliance in Indonesia’s Professional Class
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 3 Issue 1, 2023 | Sophie Lambert
Enhancing Attention in Girls with Behavioral Disabilities Through Self-Instruction in Rafha, KSA
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 5 Issue 1, 2025 | Daniel Morales
Human Dignity, Recognition, and Autonomy in Contemporary Work Systems
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Thabo Nkosi
Safety and Dissent Rights in Algorithmic Work Systems
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Ivan Petrov
Emotional Lag, Change Speed, and Adaptive Breakdown in Organizations
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Omar Khalid
How Organizational Decision Systems Automate and Amplify Workplace Inequality
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Luis Herrera
Who Receives Credit for Effort in Technology-Mediated Organizational Work?
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Peter Novak
Behavioral Autonomy, Cognitive Offloading, and Responsibility in Artificial Intelligence–Assisted Work
Journal of Applied Organizational Systems and Behavior
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Siti Rahman

About APSSHS