We'd appreciate your feedback. Send feedback Subscribe to our newsletters and alerts


Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior

2025 Volume 5

Examining the Alignment and Mismatch of University Degrees in the Graduate Job Market


, ,
  1. Department of Management, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
  2. Faculty of Economics and Business, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Abstract

This study addresses the limited research on horizontal education‑job mismatch among university graduates, which occurs when individuals work in a field different from their university training while holding a corresponding formal qualification. The analysis utilizes data from Spain’s first nationally representative survey on the labor market integration of recent university graduates. Using multinomial logistic regression, we examine graduates’ self‑assessed match status four years after graduation. Our results indicate that graduates in Chemistry, Mathematics, Physics, Pharmacy, and Languages and Literature face a higher risk of horizontal mismatch, whereas those in Medicine are more likely to secure jobs aligned with their qualifications. This suggests that horizontal mismatch is more common in degree programs emphasizing general skills and less common in those offering highly occupation‑specific skills. Degrees in Business Studies, Management, and Economics, on the other hand, are associated with a higher likelihood of vertical mismatch (over‑education), which still allows graduates to retain some of the specific human capital acquired through their studies. Conversely, graduates in Labor Relations and Social Work often occupy non‑graduate roles unrelated to their fields of study. Additionally, the findings reveal that graduates in health sciences and engineering/architecture are more likely to achieve a better education‑job fit after experiencing external job mobility.


How to cite this article
Vancouver
Rossi E, Bianchi M, Conti L. Examining the Alignment and Mismatch of University Degrees in the Graduate Job Market. Asian J Indiv Organ Behav. 2025;5:208-21. https://doi.org/10.51847/xnNR3Dr7eu
APA
Rossi, E., Bianchi, M., & Conti, L. (2025). Examining the Alignment and Mismatch of University Degrees in the Graduate Job Market. Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior, 5, 208-221. https://doi.org/10.51847/xnNR3Dr7eu
Articles
Impact of Digital Burnout on Consumer Perceptions of Online Shopping
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 4 , 2024 | Mehmet Faruk Ceylan
Consumers' Willingness to Use Mobile Taxi Booking Applications: A Theoretical Approach Based on the Theory of Planned Behavior
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 5 , 2025 | Wijesinghe Arachchilage Don Isanka Hansani
Exploring Job Satisfaction Among Pharmacists Across Various Practice Environments in Nigeria
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 5 , 2025 | Ayodapo Oluwadare Jegede
The Role of Human Capital in Driving Creativity and Innovation
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 4 , 2024 | Miriam Garbarova
The Influence of Organizational Behavior on Strategic Decision-Making
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 3 , 2023 | Salwa Abdel Hafeez Bahrawi
Experiencing Loneliness among Students at the Faculty of Science and Arts during the Covid-19 Pandemic
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 1 , 2021 | Nawal Hamid Mohammed Hamid
KWReq: A Novel Tool for Assessing the Knowledge Work Demands of Higher Education Graduates
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 5 , 2025 | Katarina Nilsson
Diversity of Experience and Its Impact on Productivity in Creative Sectors
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 5 , 2025 | Omar Khalid
Examining the Alignment and Mismatch of University Degrees in the Graduate Job Market
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 5 , 2025 | Elena Rossi
Expanding Public Early Childcare: Effects on Maternal Employment and Desired Working Hours in Germany
Asian Journal of Individual and Organizational Behavior
Vol 4 , 2024 | Maria Santos

About APSSHS